Turmoil Over Misnumbered Jefferson County Bills, Watch the Video, Take the Poll

Watch the video of the council meeting where Renee Reuter walked out in protest. What do you think? Take the poll!

Jefferson County Council Woman Renee Reuter wrote a blog, published on Fenton High Ridge on Feb. 16, about leaving a council meeting to protest 46 misnumbered bills. She left the meeting after the council voted to approve the agenda, which included the misnumbered bills.

In her blog she compared misnumbered bills to a wrong address on a deed or an incorrect VIN on your car title, which could lead to “long and expensive court battles that will be paid for by our taxes.”

“When members of the council whip out a rubber stamp and pretend they’ve been given a lobotomy,” she said, “they ignore the whole purpose of the Charter and the essence of their responsibility to the people they represent.”

County Executive Ken Waller responded to Reuter’s statements on Feb. 17, which also ran on Patch.

“Contrary to Council Woman Reuter's position, the numbering of the bills has little legal significance. What is significant is that when the bills are duly and legally passed, as they were, that the ordinance numbers are correctly placed on the bills both for historical background and for record-keeping purposes.”

He said the numbering system, "though different from previous agendas, was neither invalid, or illegal.

“The same cannot be said of Council Woman Reuter,” he said, “whose latest example of childish behavior simply illustrates her lack of professionalism and lack of responsibility to the residents of the county.”

In comments following Waller's response, County Councilman Charles Groeteke defended Reuter, and Arnold City Councilman Bill Moritz came up on Waller’s side. Further comments also took opposing sides.

What do you think? Do you agree with Reuter or Waller? Take the poll at the bottom of the article.

The county council records all its meetings on video. The following is a summary of events leading up to Reuter leaving the meeting. The times correspond to the clock shown at the bottom of the screen in the video. You can use the slider to go to specific times.

6:51 p.m.

 Reuter begins a Powerpoint presentation that points out the misnumbered bills.  

7:24 p.m.

Reuter makes a motion, which is seconded, to change the numbers in the 46 bills, as she requested in her presentation. Don Bickowski , Reuter and Groeteke, vote yes, to change the numbers. Council Chair Bob Boyer, Teresa Kreitler, Cliff Lane, and Kelly Waymon vote no.

7:25 p.m.

Reuter moves to remove all the misnumbered items from the agenda, “so we don’t pass something inadvertently that is not according to the rules and history of this fine body.” A councilman requests she list the items, and she did.

7:27 p.m.

After Reuter lists the bills, the vote is taken to have them removed, and it goes exactly as the vote to rename the bills. Bickowski, Reuter and Groeteke, vote yes, to remove the items. Boyer, Kreitler, Lane and Waymon vote no.

7:28 p.m.

There is a motion to approve the agenda. That vote is the mirror opposite of the two previous votes. Bickowski, Reuter and Groeteke, vote no. Boyer, Kreitler, Lane and Waymon vote yes, to approve the agenda, keeping the misnumbered bills.

Soon after that vote, Reuter begins to get her papers together, and just before 7:30 p.m., without a word, gets up and leaves the room.

An announcement is made, “Point of order, please note that Council Woman Reuter left the room at 7:29 p.m.”

Bob Usher February 21, 2012 at 01:44 PM
She made a motion, it was seconded, voted on, and she lost. She needs to grow up.
Patrick Crowley February 21, 2012 at 04:24 PM
Renee is correct. If it is worth doing it is therefore worth doing right and right the first time. Allowing labeling errors into the systems will cause these to be lost with time. Take heart, Renee, stupid people do not stand on solid ground so they will fall by the wayside eventually.
Bob Usher February 21, 2012 at 04:49 PM
There are two different issues at play here. One is following the rules of order, the other is the issue that was being decided. If you follow Robert's rules of order and you lose, you don't just get up and leave, you try and make you case. Her job is to represent the people that put her in that position, and she can't do that if she is absent.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »